How does Arts
Integration Work?
The Why-
I’ll bet you’re thinking— I now know all about Betsy Rubino, but
what about integrating English and Theater subject matter? Well, I heard you
and have prepared an integrated five-day mini-unit lesson plan to support my
premise that the Arts provide differentiated access to the core subjects.
The Plan
My plan consists of integrating fables with theater activities
in order to meet the CCSS English Reading Standards of RL6.2, 6.3, Listening
and Speaking Standards SL 6.4, and 6.6. The activities also meet the Theater
Standards of 2.2 and 2.3. Summarily, the
plan teaches students to sequence (using details), identify character traits,
and the theme of a fable, by retelling the story through performance.
The Pre-assessment
As with any good plan, Arts Integration starts with a
pre-assessment to evaluate the student’s prior knowledge and readiness to learn
new concepts. Since it’s summer, I asked a small group of 6th, 7th
and 8th grade Arts Camp Counselors-in-Training, to join me during
their free time. My first challenge came when, after cursory questioning, I
discovered that only one student had actually ever had a theater class. While
at first feeling perplexed as to next steps, I decided this was the perfect
opportunity to test my premise that English and Theater subjects are easily
integrated.
Realizing that this unit is based on prior knowledge and
exposure to fables, I started the pre-assessment by asking, “What is a fable?”
only to be greeted by blank stares! Ahhh, summer! After a quick Think Pair
Share with a partner, the conversation got started. The question came up as to
what was the difference between a fairytale and fable. Taking this as a
teachable moment, I gave them my computer and let them research and discuss the
question. This conversation was a perfect segue to the planned pre-assessment. I
gave the instructions and checked for understanding (Fisher and Frey, 2007).
They then chose a recorder, timekeeper, leader, and reporter (Tate, NU lecture)
The small group discussion began but when I saw the recorder struggling to keep
up, I adjusted the plan so the recorder was only responsible to write the
questions. Each student was to record his or her own answers. This helped the
recorder keep face and speed up the process. My approach was to observe the
discussion and make one visit to the group for each question. This was helpful
since I was able to ask clarifying questions. They posted their papers on the
wall and we reviewed them.
The Results:
During the group work, their discussion was respectful; they
were all engaged, and focused. After an uncertain start, they were able to list
several fables and identify common morals/themes. They struggled with the
characteristics of a fable and the types of characters found in fables. In the
Whip Around (Rutherford, 2012) Adam, Leah and Sofia were unable to identify the
fable that went with the moral I presented. Whereas they all seemed to have a
concrete concept of a moral and its connection to a fable they were not able to
clearly connect the moral to a real life situation.
The pre-assessment was meant to identify weaknesses in thinking
and understanding of fables and check for readiness to learn and apply the new
concepts and skills. The question and
answer discussion identified the need
for further work on fable characteristics and character types which is what the
mini-unit is configured to teach. Even though these students have been exposed
to fables their learning has not emphasized the purpose of fables.
Adjustments: Overall, the
pre-assessment is a valuable tool to determine if the students are prepared for
the content and it shows the areas they are weak. My adjustment to the plan
would be to add the question, “What is a fable? “ prior to small group
discussion. Whereas I had planned to put
a group of fables out later in the week, I think it might be good to let
students browse through them before class starts. It took some prodding for
this group to focus and recall what constitutes a fable. Another adjustment
would be the time. I think the pre-assessment took too long but a lack of
regular classroom tools, such as chart paper and a white board also hindered it.
The students seemed to enjoy the pre-assessment and worked hard
to fulfill the requirements. They communicated and cooperated just like a real
classmates. I really enjoyed having time to discuss and analyze the questions.
Using the computer to research their own question also engaged them so I would
like to embed the same sort of activity the next time.